Ice Cream in Verona, WI | Icki Sticki Cafe
If you are looking for ice cream in Verona, WI, Icki Sticki at 407 W Verona Ave is your go-to spot. We serve locally made ice cream scoops, indulgent Frappes blended with your choice of ice cream, and housemade Shaved Ice in a welcoming cafe that Verona families and regulars call their favorite stop. We are open Monday through Friday from 6 AM to 8 PM and Saturday through Sunday from 7 AM to 8 PM. If you want to know what drives the experience here, you can learn more about what makes our cafe different.
Call (608) 301-6346, stop by at 407 W Verona Ave, Verona, WI 53593, or order online to satisfy your ice cream craving.
What Is Specialty Ice Cream and Why Icki Sticki Does It Differently
Specialty ice cream is not soft serve from a machine or a grocery store pint pulled out of a freezer. It is locally made, small-batch ice cream crafted with quality ingredients — the kind where you can actually taste the difference in every scoop.
At Icki Sticki, we serve locally made ice cream at our Verona location. That means fresher product, real flavor, and a scoop that actually tastes like something. We also blend our ice cream directly into our Frappes and offer housemade Shaved Ice as a lighter option for warmer days.
We also make our whipped cream and syrups in-house. Not out of a can, not from a commercial supplier. Made fresh every day because that is the standard we hold ourselves to.
This is ice cream in Verona, WI made by people who live in the same community they are serving. Not a chain. Not a formula. Just quality ice cream done right at 407 W Verona Ave.
Our ice cream menu is built around quality, not gimmicks:
- Locally made ice cream scoops served fresh
- Frappes blended to order with your choice of ice cream
- Housemade Shaved Ice with rotating flavors
- Housemade whipped cream on every Frappe
- A welcoming cafe space that is comfortable for families and individuals alike
Ice Cream in Verona, WI: What We Serve
Classic Scoops
Our locally made ice cream is available by the scoop and best enjoyed in the cafe or taken to go. Ask our crew what is fresh and available. Flavors rotate and we love helping you find your new favorite.
Frappes: Ice Cream Blended Into Your Coffee
Our Frappe takes the ice cream in Verona experience to a completely different level. We blend your choice of ice cream directly into a coffee Frappe, top it with our housemade whipped cream, and hand it to you ready to enjoy. At $10.50, it is our most indulgent item and one of the most popular orders at this location.
It is rich, creamy, and completely made to order. The kind of treat that makes you stop and pay attention to what you are eating.
Housemade Shaved Ice
Looking for something lighter? Our housemade Shaved Ice is a Verona warm-weather staple. Fluffy, flavorful, and refreshing, it is the kind of treat that brings people back every summer without fail. Perfect for kids, perfect for hot days, and honestly perfect for any day you want something a little different.
Why Verona Residents Come Here for Ice Cream
Verona is an active, tight-knit community. With the Sugar River Trail running right through town, Epic Systems drawing thousands of employees to the area, and a growing number of families settling in neighborhoods along West Verona Ave and nearby corridors, there is no shortage of people looking for a great local spot to unwind.
According to Visit Wisconsin, community gathering spots and locally owned food and beverage businesses are among the top reasons residents report strong satisfaction with small Wisconsin cities. Icki Sticki is exactly that kind of place.
We are not a tourist destination. We are your neighborhood cafe. When you want ice cream in Verona, WI that comes with a real sense of place and people who are genuinely glad you walked in, this is where you come.
Parents bring their kids here after soccer practice. Coworkers stop in after a long day at the office. Trail riders make us their first or last stop. Locals who have been coming since we opened still walk through the door like they own the place, because in a way, they do. This is their cafe.
How We Make Every Visit Worth It at Icki Sticki Verona
From the moment you walk in or place your order online, our Verona team is focused on one thing: making sure you leave happy. We source locally made ice cream, prepare everything fresh to order, and keep our hours wide open so you never have to plan around us. Here is what you can expect when you visit:
Frappes: Blended coffee and ice cream for when you want both worlds at once
Housemade Shaved Ice: Light, refreshing, and endlessly customizable
Classic Scoops: Locally made and served fresh every day
Housemade whipped cream and syrups: Made in-house, on every order, every time
Pair your order with one of our specialty lattes or cold brews — ask our crew what pairs best with your scoop. See what our regulars keep coming back for in our Top 5 Comforting Cafe Favorites in Wisconsin.
Ready to order? Browse our full menu and order online here.
How to Get Your Ice Cream at Icki Sticki Verona
Getting your order is simple. Here is how it works:
Step 1 — Choose how you want to order. Walk in at 407 W Verona Ave or order ahead through our app or online at online.order.infi.us. Either way works — we are ready for you.
Step 2 — Pick your treat. Go with a classic scoop, a Frappe blended with your choice of ice cream, or a housemade Shaved Ice. Not sure? Our crew will help you find the right fit.
Step 3 — Made fresh to order. Everything is made when you order it. No sitting under a heat lamp, no shortcuts. Just fresh, quality ice cream the way it should be.
Step 4 — Pick it up and enjoy. If you ordered ahead, it will be waiting when you arrive. If you are walking in, we will have it ready in minutes.
Skip the Line and Order Your Ice Cream Faster
Call (608) 301-6346, stop by at 407 W Verona Ave, or order online to save time and have your order ready when you arrive.
Why Choose Icki Sticki for Ice Cream in Verona, WI
We opened our Verona location because this community deserved a cafe that felt like it actually belonged here. Not a franchise. Not a formula. A real neighborhood spot built by people who live and work in the same community they serve. Family-owned and locally operated since 2019 — no corporate parent, no franchise fees, just neighbors serving neighbors.
Here is what sets us apart:
Serving Verona since 2019 — one of the first specialty cafes to open on West Verona Ave
A favorite stop for Sugar River Trail riders — locals make us their first stop in the morning and their last stop after a ride
Known by the Epic Systems community — thousands of Epic employees make Icki Sticki part of their daily routine
Locally made ice cream you cannot get at a chain — we source real, small-batch ice cream because Verona deserves better than mass-produced
Housemade whipped cream and syrups on every order — made in-house every day, not out of a can
A crew that has been serving the same neighbors for years — our Verona team knows regulars by name and by order
Online ordering built for busy Verona schedules — order ahead and skip the line, no account required
Since opening in 2019, Icki Sticki has served thousands of Verona families and has become one of the most reviewed cafes in the area. Our regulars come back weekly — many have been visiting since our first week open. That kind of loyalty does not come from a formula. It comes from genuinely caring about every single order.
Frequently Asked Questions About Ice Cream in Verona, WI
Do you serve ice cream at the Verona location?
Yes. Our Verona location at 407 W Verona Ave serves locally made ice cream scoops, Frappes blended with your choice of ice cream, and housemade Shaved Ice. We are open 7 days a week.
What is a Frappe at Icki Sticki?
Our Frappe is a blended coffee drink made with your choice of ice cream and topped with housemade whipped cream. It is $10.50 and one of the most popular items we serve. It is part coffee drink, part ice cream treat, and completely worth it.
Do you have ice cream options for kids?
Absolutely. Our ice cream scoops and housemade Shaved Ice are both kid favorites and a great reason to bring the whole family in. We are a family-friendly cafe and love seeing young faces at the counter.
Can I order ice cream online at the Verona location?
Yes. You can order ahead through our online ordering system at online.order.infi.us or through the Icki Sticki app on iOS and Android. Your order will be ready when you arrive.
What are your hours at the Verona location?
We are open Monday through Friday from 6 AM to 8 PM and Saturday through Sunday from 7 AM to 8 PM. Come in anytime.
Do you have other locations in Wisconsin?
Yes. You can also find us in Madison at 410 D’Onofrio Drive and in Mt. Horeb at 1225 Springdale St. Same great ice cream in Verona WI quality and the same crew that genuinely cares, just closer to wherever you are.
Get Your Ice Cream Today
If you are ready for a scoop, a Frappe, or a cup of Shaved Ice made right, you can explore the full menu and order ahead so your order is ready when you arrive. You can also view our Verona location on Google Maps to plan your visit and find the easiest route.
Get Your Ice Cream Without the Wait
Call (608) 301-6346, stop by at 407 W Verona Ave, Verona, WI 53593, or order online and get your ice cream in Verona, WI without the wait | Email: info@ickisticki.com
Disclaimer
This page is for general information about our ice cream and dessert offerings. Flavor availability may vary depending on demand and timing. Visit us or order online to see what is fresh today.